Backstory
For those who don’t know yet, Identity Crisis is the first major storyline that I’m running with Patrick McCarthy in the newly reopened SCCW. The premise for the storyline centers around how McCarthy entered the two previous incarnations of SCCW: as part of a tag team. McCarthy first “big break” in the business was when Jay Jerzey’s partner was injured while holding the Tag Team titles. Jerzey, instead of dropping the belts, elected to select a relative unknown and green-as-goose-shit rookie as his tag partner. Thus, Patrick McCarthy became part of Youthanazia (which Cory continuously misspells). When McCarthy returned to the Canadian indy circuit it was in a SCCW splinter-fed: Pure Honor Wrestling (PHW). Pure Honor Wrestling was later merged with Central Ontario Pro Wrestling (COPW) which would become SCCW. The tag belts had to be unified, so as one-half of the PHW Tag Team champions Patrick McCarthy came back to SCCW as part of S & M with Scarlett Willis.
With SCCW returning, it only makes sense that the only man to ever hold the SCCW, PHW and COPW tag team titles should return as part of a tag team… But which one? With Jay Jerzey and Scarlett Willis both returning, McCarthy is left at a crossroads. On the one hand, the last tag team he was a part of was S & M, and they were undefeated and unmatched in their time in COPW/SCCW. On the other hand, McCarthy and Scarlett haven’t spoken in three years since they broke off their engagement and she moved back how to Utah, leaving him in Canada.
That’s what you need to know in terms of backstory.
Recently
During the promos leading up to the first Monday Night Aggression, Jay Jerzey hinted not only having been in contact with Patrick McCarthy, as the two are supposedly close friends in the business/sport, but also that Youthanazia would be returning to SCCW. Conversely, Scarlett Willis talked about her misgivings about being teamed with Patrick again and the deep-seat emotions that such a pairing might bring out of her. For his on part, McCarthy physically became ill from feelings of guilt, remorse and heartbreak upon seeing Scarlett’s first promo and hearing her refer to him as “he who shall remain nameless” (missing the part about how talking about him would cause her emotional stress).
At the first MNA, McCarthy and Scarlett had an awkward encounter in the backstage area. Trying to find the words to reconcile the time they spent apart. This was interrupted by Jay Jerzey making his best effort to “save” McCarthy from an obviously awkward situation and then trying to coax McCarthy into reforming Youthanazia. While McCarthy remained aloof in the face of Jerzey’s persistence, he did agree to a one-off tag match for the second MNA. Meanwhile, the newly reformed S & M team picked up their first win over Kirsta Lewis and Rayne Young in the main event.
During the match, McCarthy became visibly irate at the physical abuse ditched out on Scarlett. As a character known for his calm and collected manner, this was a far departure for him. Later on when the “hot tag” to McCarthy was reversed by the official, McCarthy shoved the referee and attacked his opponents, almost earning a DQ. When Rayne Young demanded that Scarlett get back in the ring – as she was still the legal wrestler according to the referee – McCarthy stood between Young and Scarlett and refused to give up his ground until Scarlett was able to re-enter under her own power. This showing of protectiveness and ire were meant to demonstrate that McCarthy obviously still have feelings for Scarlett that go beyond that of a tag team partner. It is also worth noting that in the match, McCarthy and Scarlett displayed good chemistry, working in tandem, as if they hadn’t spent 3 years apart.
I actually enjoyed writing the Main Event, because I feel not enough story-telling is done DURING the matches. That is the whole point of wrestling afterall: storytelling via wrestling.
Moving Forward
I don’t want to give too much away about what’s happening moving forward, but McCarthy has small angles and segments lined up with the “mysterious” new owner, as well as something involving the Bunkhouse Brawl to determine the first SCCW Heavyweight champion, the Legacy title, and the All Barrie Tag Titles. The tag line for whole Identity Crisis storyline is based on the Spiderman “Identity Crisis” series where Spiderman became a wanted criminal so Peter Parker adopted several new identities such as Prodigy and Dusk. The comics would have titles like “If Spiderman is Dusk, the who is Prodigy?” which is where I got “If Patrick McCarthy is in S & M, then who is in Youthanazia?” The same basic premise is that a man can’t serve two masters, or be in two places at the same time. Eventually everything will come to a head.
Down the line, but not too far down, a big feud (actually two) is scheduled to evolve out of this storyline.
Stay tuned here for little news and notes on my RPs and maybe some in-character stuff coming soon!
- V

